Used stamps exchanges.

Why 2 star rating ??? I see lots of conmemoratives and no damages. Just old album marks in few stamps. The other, fullfill rules. Why 2 star ?'
Would you like to be rated under same criteria ??
this is not fair, this is not nice

I put 2 because of damaged stamps especially stained with rust very contagious for other stamps

if you want them, I put the whole thing aside for a future exchange

Avec plaisir. Ça fera 2 etoiles aussi si c'est vous qui les envoyez ??
C'est ça la discussion que je propose.
Avec ces 2 etoiles, Makari est bloqué pendant les prochaines 10 references
Pourquoi ??
Est-ce qu'il faut vraiment qualifier avec 2 etoiles ??

I would systematically put 2 if there are stamps with rust spots (fungus)

it becomes painful to receive this kind of stamps, you only have to do less exchange if you cannot give good quality stamps

Such stamps can be repaired as well as colored from a pencil by immersion in boiling water

Hello, from my side I would like to say that I accept the 2 stars and I will use this to try to improve, but I do not agree, there are 100 stamps or alomost in good conditions.

By the way, it was also painful for me to have to throw away the 3 or 4 french stamps from your envelope because you put adhesive tape on them and they were spoiled, and despite this "lack of care", I rated you with 5 stars because anyone would make a mistake.

I do not want to argue with you, if you consider that I deserve 2 stars I accept it. In almost all the letters I receive lately I throw away 6 or 7 stamps that arrive wrong and I do not take it into account for the rating of the lot...

May I ask what your rating would be if I send you 50 spanish stamps despite you don't want them? just to know in case I will be given your name again.

Best regards

2

Giving 1 or 2 star like this, only helps to make a bad environment among us. I dont know why you Laurent, rate 2 stars to Makari. I cannot understand. If you dont like it, give a 3 star, but taking into consideration club rules, you might put Makari out of this game.

Maybe you would like to be like this ??

Camulus !!! You always help to team build

I would give 5star, if very angry 3 star, but never 1 or 2 star unles really deserved.

@ Makari

if they are in good condition, no rust stain toothless, folded, I would give 5

I understand that we cannot send what we do not have but it is enough to exchange less if we can not give good quality stamps regardless of the country

@ francescpf

I have nothing against Makari, I do not even know him, ok now I do as certain here and I send anything whatever the note


I systematically take pictures of what I send and what I receive


francescpf ---> Why did you score 4.58, and 4.68 (two profiles)
and you allow yourself to put a 1 a erling (4.98) for either an empty envelope or just for revenge

I dont have 2 profiles. I didnt rate 1 star to Anyone il y a tres longtemps. Je vous comprends pas

Erling?? I will give him always 5 star before opening

The issue here is the gentleman behaviour.

Sorry no Erling but Nielst

it is not Camulus who destroys a team but people who send their residues and who will annoy the rest of the participants who respect the rules

the rule

100 used stamps.

Unique stamps, no doubles.

Stamps in good condition
Stamps in good condition
Stamps in good condition

it's not complicated

they are in good condition, what I see in picture is marks of glue, not oxid
anyway... how many in bad condition under your eyes ?? not enough to rate 2

and once again, I have not rated anyone 1 or 2 star, not in the last 2 years at least
I dont know what you are meaning
anyway... rating 1-2 stars dont help to build teams

i will leave your talk alone, but i have to say about what i see
i see hinge - this is not a damage and also pen writings on back - not damage, since a lot of stamps is written on - i get a lot and i leave it alone

nachopl

francescpf

francescpf is me
nachopl is my son
what is the issue here ??

it means you are very worried about us :):)
we are popular... are we ?? :)

@Krepi ---which poses a problem I'm talking about rust , toothless, it's nothing the writing or the hinges

@Ziga I have 50% good news for you .)
in private later

Makari stamps are in good condition
maybe is because we are Spanish ¿¿??

you both have a good grade , your son and you

Spain has nothing to do with that, I note as I want, (otherwise you have to remove the note 1 and 2) it does not suit you, no one is forcing you to send stamps

@Laurent >> je me suis mis dans la discussion parce que 1-2 star ne fait que du broullard et mauvaise ambiance
Si tu n'aime pas les timbres de Makari, laissez-lui avec 3, parce que avec 1-2 etoiles, il est bloqué pendant 2-3 mois au ritme de la poste. Si les prochaines 2 references sont en Indie ou la Russie, il sera bloqué pour presque 4-6 mois, jusqu'à qu'il arrive à 10 nouveaux contacts

Hi all, please, let's not make a big issue of this.

Laurent has the right to rate as he considers and I have to accept I didn't review properly the stamps in this lot. We are here to make fun, if I have to be punished some time, t's ok.

Laurent, I always comply with the rules, I have more that 283 lot sent and this is my first negative rate, in the last 12 months I had 45 positive ratings and 3 neutral ratings (because of common stamps or not complying with wishes, I'm happy to hear that you rate the same wether the stamps comply with your whises or not, but not everybody here do the same), in fact this is my third lot for you, the first one rated with 5 and the second one rated with 4. I'm not destroying here nothing but stamps in bad coditions I recieved and I don't want to resend to anybody, but in this case maybe I didn't review your stamps as well as I should.

francescpf, many thanks for your support, but let's finish this here.

Best regards

moi particulierment, il faut une situation tres grave pour 1-2 etoiles
hônetment... pas mal de fois les 5 etoiles arrivent que avec l'envelope

@makari >> oido cocina :)

@ francescpf -> we already know that you are well languaged. Maybe for a discussion we should maintain ONE laguage (for better communication :)