I agree with francescpf, German stamps are very attractive and well postmarked for used ones. I am happy to receive them in any trade. I have most earlier issues but I still need some recent from last few years. Even if you receive German issues and don't need them, that's no reason to give a reduced rating. If all stamps are not damaged then they fall in the rules of the club. To give low rating just because you say "don't send German stamps" is not the aim of this club. Maybe the sender just doesn't have enough of your "wants" to fulfill your request. Remember, "undamaged, different, deserves a 5 regardless of what you say in your profile. Happy stamping.