Used stamps exchanges.

I'm sorry to give a negative rating, it's the first time I have ever given less than 5 stars. However as per the rules of the exchange, the stamps sent must be in good condition. This person sent 15 stamps in very bad condition - these ones have bad creases, big parts of the corner missing, dark yellow stains, staple holes etc. If I was being more picky, at least 50% of the stamps have some kind of imperfection. I don't mind that my preferences weren't followed because that's not a rule, it's still a blind swap after all.

Dear Emily, thanks for the rating (2 stars), I didn’t even want to answer you because it’s not worth it). Maybe you’re right for a few corners less in stamps, but from the picture I see 4/5 and no 15 as you say, Anyway, I think you can understand that the stamps we then send around are the repeated stamps we receive from the various exchanges and then we send back. I can assure you that I have a few kilograms left over, unusable, received all with defects and missing angles,( I have always given 3 stars up, but never 2 stars, so someone can happen to send it to me too, I would have understood receiving 3 stars but no 2 stars. However I thank you because I understood that in this club the ratings are personal and this affects the work and expenses incurred by others. Surely this will be the last exchange in this club, thanks to you.

you shouldn't blame Feijoa_girl. It is you who sent these stamps not anyone else. From all the kilograms you have you probably could have picked better stamps. These stamps just aren't very attractive.
Looking at your rating it is not the first time you've sent stamps like these. I think 2* is a fair rating

If you look at the quality of the stamps that most of the other people on this group are sending, you will see that this is well below that. I can accept a few damaged stamp in a lot if there is something else good in there, but the undamaged stamps here are mostly ones that I take one look and and throw in the garbage since they are so very common.

Stars received: 3.76

just see the overall rating, you send your residues