Used stamps exchanges.

I received an almost identical lot. I did not down grade it, but I would say it was a bit disappointing.

To PaulThiessen: You should have given a rating of 2 also. When you rate all 5, just give you a lower revenge as a revenge. This is cowardice.

To all:
FPINTO04 sends very bad stamps and has already had many negative ratings. On Colnect it works by excluding members with 3 negative ratings.

I support Paul Thiessen. Being a polite gentleman is something you cannot buy, you simply are.

francescpf: This is not about courtesy and gentlemen. You're obviously mistaken. Giving everyone a rating of 5 (even if he sent bad stamps), just to give you a response, is a calculation to get a good rating at any cost, because you're afraid that if you give someone a low rating, he will also give you low rating. So it's cowardice!!!

hello Camulus :)
Im not mentioning you, not writting to you. Im simply supporting my friend Thiessen in his comment.
I appreciate you take a couple of minutes to think about me :)
sorry for misunderstanding :):)
you are also a gentleman, of course :)
I hope you do not feel driven in my comment to Paul. I simply support him, thats all

sorry again... I was writting while registering with my son, and forgot to change, but it is ok, everybody knows here my son and me "work" together :)

yup - he sends bad stuff, but when he receives everything is 4
i received bad lot too, but i was a bit of gentleman and i gave neutral (3)

Exactly Krepki my case. I gave him a rating 3, he as revenge gave me also 3. So I wrote to him that his lot was very bad and that no one stamp could be used in my list, different from my lot for him. So then he changed his rating to 4. So it's all about revenge and not about gentlemen. If at school the teachers gave all students only one rating, it would probably be a proper anarchy.

Had a same lot. Rated it 3, because I find it to much work to upload photo's. This person should be removed from this club.

I received an almost identical lot also
Was a nice guy, I don't believe in giving less then 3 star
I guess it meets club rules, have to be neutral on stamps received, 5 damage , 16 stamps on paper, few duplicates. Plus 14 Portugal stamps may not be used as a postage stamp, so far they don't exist in Scott Catalog