Used stamps exchanges.

Why 2 star?

This looks nice selection

Why is this 2 star? looks OK

Perhaps not enough (100) stamps ?

Hi all

20 bad ones ( yellowed because badly washed and some defaults).
The more in my profile I ask not to send German stamps. 80 were German...

this kind of pictures tell us anything. 20 bad stamps? But how many did you receive in total?
At least show all the stamps, and make clear what the 'defaults' are.
Ypu talk about 80 Germans, but also see Canadian Danish and Norwegian stamps

Profiles are just a wish. Maybe a guideline how to make you satisfied.
Well it's clear that Pitti didn't succeed.
I can't see a reason for giving a 2*.

Profile are not MANDATORY

I would change rating

This practice discourages new members.

Joker, who are you? 0 exchanges and you go here to teach what is mandatory. Profiles are used to make the wishes written in them fulfilled. The bad guy ignores them and then don't be surprised that he gets a rating of 2 - because he deserves it. If someone does not want German stamps, then a good person will not send them. That is all. Only ignoramuses do not follow.

hello Cumulus :)
and who are you ?? profiles are not MANDATORY, and you know
the good guy has sent 100 stamps following basic club rules, and you know
he does not deserve 2 star rating
I see conmemorative stamps, Canada stamps, other countries stamps... what is wrong ??
Supporting these rates is not a good feeling Im afraid

If you dont like, I would switch to 3 star, but 1-2 star again, gets member out of the club
is that we all want ??

Very, very interesting comment from a member (since 2018), who hasn´t even sent one letter!!
Maybe it´s better to join a gossip club.

But I´m the opinion that 2 stars are not fair for these stamps, I can see on the scan.

Many bad stamps (20 damaged) would justify a bad rating although 2 star is quite low. But it seems that some are making their own rules ("Many not in scope stamps and CTO stamps imply a bad rating !"). Is it now mandatory to meet someone's profile? CTO's I understand (learned the hard way), but out of scope resulting in bad ratings is not the standard in this club, or am I wrong?