Used stamps exchanges.

Such stamps are not being sent. Every collector has a lot of these stamps. It's a classic - definite stamps. A merit rating that should serve as a warning to anyone who wants to send such stamps.

On the other hand it seems that club rules were fulfilled. There are 163 stamps, so there have to be 100 different stamps in good condition. Only 10 stamps on the image seems to be slightly damaged. I agree that I don´t want to receive a lot like this, but it should be 3 stars, especially for completely new member...

Juras, I agree with you. She is a new member, she wrote the rules. So, I think that the negative rating should be for those members who breaks the rules of the club. Of course, we as experienced philatelists don't want to receive so many usual definitive stamps, but first we have to change the rules of this 100stamps club. IMHO.

Even these postage stamps of a number of philatelists are looking for. Not the majority, maximal 20, over and above the number 100 stamps. For me to maximal 20 definitive stamps not a problem.

This lot can be interesting for a serious collector as some of this stamps have rare variants.
It should be 3 stars, as those are almost all tradable stamps. So a kean collector would know where to trade them for stamps needed. I love definitives and I get lot of them here, often 50%+, there are also lot of collectors that do not know the diff between def and comm, tell they do not want def's but sending out a lot of them. Mariana have very mild requests for stamps but she should have sent some from her own country.

Anyone who gets such stamps is not happy ... it's waste.

When I send a lot I always ask myself the question: would I be happy if I receive this lot? If the answer is an honest Yes, than it's okay. I would never, ever send such a lot, even as a new member I didn't. You have probably a lot of these yourself, at least you should realize the receiver has got most of them too.
The sender may have fulfilled all the rules but in my opinion the club is more than sending 100 stamps that are all different, in good condition...I think everybody should try to send nice stamps of which the chances are bigger that quite a few are useful.
I have a whole box of German stamps, it would be easy to send 100 different ones, scoring 5 stars because I fulfilled all the rules, but I think the thought behind the club is more than that. Doing your very best for the receiver! Gerard

Danubius told about rating (at the bottom - 23 Apr 2018):
http://100stamps.club/discussions/messages/174