For some people it's never good: 110 stamps, so 10% to make up for any missed defects jsut in case, all pre 1990 as per the members wish and all flowers,animals, cartoons. I really spent some time to sort this out for him and then you get a 4 start rating! this sucks hard time and these kind of members make me sometimes think about quitting this club. I get dozens of unwanted stuff - cto, very commom defs etc - but give 5 star rating because the 100 different rule has been met, I only give 4 or 3 if there's more than 10 or so damaged. I do my very best to send good stuff according to peoples wishes. I never send cto, unless someone states he likes it because of motives and I only give definitives as extras. And this is the reward. I'm not the only one, he never ever has given 5 star, but I just had to share it. I'm over it now:-)