This looks nice choice of stamps. Damaged envelope while teavelling maybe. I dont think it is 2 star.
If we all start rating 1-2 star for nithing, many members will duscourage
Maybe two stars is a little bit hard. Actually Seamusk has good ratings.
Bent stamps are often the result of postal handling, but they can be burnished, except there are kinked corners, which I can not really see at the scan.
YOu maybe dont like that choice, but in my opinion, is under club rules. Seamusk has good average rating, so he does not deserve 2 star. I think it should be restored to a right rating. 1-2 star, when not really necessary... are not right.